Alabama Will Contests: 2026 Probate Court Rules

Alabama couple reviewing a will and probate records with an attorney

Disagreements over a loved one’s will can involve questions about signatures, mental capacity, family pressure, or the distribution of valuable property. Alabama families dealing with these disputes should understand the state’s filing deadlines and rules for deciding which court hears the case.

Effective October 1, 2026, Alabama Act 2026-226 clarifies when certain will contests and estate-administration proceedings can move from probate court to circuit court. The amendment is a technical correction to an existing process, not a new right to challenge every will or an extension of the deadline to file a contest.

What Changed Under Alabama Act 2026-226?

Senate Bill 195 amended Alabama Code Section 43-8-216 by expressly stating that a qualifying interested person may remove a will contest or estate-administration proceeding from probate court to circuit court without assigning any special equity. The bill became Act 2026-226 and took effect October 1, 2026.

The Alabama State Bar’s legislative update described the measure as correcting wording inadvertently omitted from the 2022 statute. The enrolled text of Senate Bill 195 sets out the amendment and existing removal procedures.

Family reviewing will documents and probate records with an Alabama attorney

What Is a Will Contest in Alabama?

A will contest is a legal proceeding challenging whether a document should be accepted as a valid will. The person bringing the challenge needs a legally recognized interest in the estate. Being disappointed with an inheritance is not, by itself, proof that the document is invalid.

Possible objections include improper execution, lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, or another legally sufficient ground. For example, evidence that the testator did not understand the nature of the will may raise a different issue from a claim that someone pressured the testator to change beneficiaries.

Alabama’s will-execution statute, Section 43-8-131, generally requires a written will signed by the testator and at least two qualifying witnesses. A dispute about execution should be evaluated against the law applicable to the particular document.

What Is the Deadline to Contest a Will?

Under Alabama Code Section 43-8-215, an interested person generally may contest a will before probate or within 180 days after the will is admitted to probate. The challenge must be filed in the court specified by the statute, with the required written allegations.

The 180-day rule is not the same as having six calendar months from the date of death. A family should confirm the actual date of probate admission and the governing procedural rules instead of relying on an approximate deadline.

Limited statutory exceptions exist for certain minors and people of unsound mind who meet specific conditions. Those exceptions should not be assumed to apply to an ordinary late filing. Prompt attention is important whenever the validity of a will is questioned.

Does a Will Contest Start in Probate Court?

For wills governed by the current Alabama procedures, the probate court where the will is offered generally has original jurisdiction over the challenge. A will contest is not automatically filed as a brand-new circuit court action merely because someone wants a jury trial.

In the 2026 decision Glenn v. Caldwell, the Alabama Supreme Court discussed the importance of following the statutory forum and removal procedures. The decision illustrates why selecting the correct court matters before filing.

Some counties have probate courts with concurrent equity jurisdiction under special constitutional or statutory provisions. That can affect whether the ordinary removal procedure is available in the particular county.

When Can a Will Contest Move to Circuit Court?

The 2026 amendment addresses removal under Alabama Code Section 43-8-216. A qualifying interested person may use this procedure when the statutory conditions are met, including the applicable county-jurisdiction requirements.

For a will contest, Section 43-8-215 generally requires removal no later than 42 days before the first trial setting, unless the probate court grants leave for good cause. This deadline is separate from the 180-day deadline for starting the contest.

What Must a Notice of Removal Include?

Section 43-8-216 requires a notice of removal filed with the circuit court. The notice must identify the nature of the proceeding, the removing party’s interest, and the interested people who will receive notice. For a will contest, it also identifies the petitioner seeking probate, the contestant, and whether a jury trial is demanded.

After filing with the circuit clerk, the removing party must file a copy with the probate clerk and send copies to the listed interested persons. The circuit court takes jurisdiction upon filing of the removal notice under the statute. The probate court then generally stops acting on the removed matter unless it is returned, apart from transmitting its record.

Families should keep copies of the filed notice and delivery records. Missing parties or failure to follow required procedures may produce disputes or delays.

Can Estate Administration Also Be Removed?

Yes, in qualifying cases. But an estate-administration removal has different timing restrictions from a will contest. Under Section 43-8-216, removal generally cannot occur before the probate court issues letters testamentary, letters of administration, or letters of administration with the will annexed. It also cannot occur after the probate court has taken steps toward final settlement under that section.

Those letters establish a personal representative’s authority to administer the probate estate. Families should distinguish a disagreement about a will’s validity from a disagreement over how a valid estate is being managed.

For a separate look at simplified administration, Anderson Law Group’s article on the Alabama Small Estates Act discusses the summary distribution process for qualifying estates.

Can a Circuit Court Send the Case Back?

Yes. The law allows a circuit court to remand a removed proceeding to probate court for reasons including improper delay, noncompliance with removal law, completion of the contested issues, or a request by all interested parties or their representatives.

The statute also allows costs to be assessed when a lawyer or party removes a proceeding vexatiously or for an improper purpose. A removal decision should therefore be tied to the facts and legal procedure, not used simply to burden other heirs.

What Evidence Can Matter in a Will Contest?

The evidence depends on the grounds raised. A family might need the original will, earlier drafts, witness information, correspondence with the drafting attorney, medical records obtained lawfully, financial documents, and communications around the time the will was signed.

When undue influence is alleged, the court may need to examine relationships, involvement in preparing the will, and the circumstances surrounding execution. A capacity dispute may require evidence concerning the testator’s understanding at the relevant time rather than general assumptions about age or illness.

Personal representatives should also identify property correctly. Bank accounts, jointly owned assets, and properly funded trusts may transfer differently from property controlled by a will. Anderson Law Group’s guide to avoiding probate in Alabama explains several common nonprobate arrangements.

Alabama family discussing an estate dispute and financial records with a lawyer

How Should Families Prepare for an Estate Dispute?

Before filing or responding to a contest, gather the following records when you can obtain them lawfully:

  • The original will and any known earlier versions.
  • The petition for probate and the order admitting the will.
  • Letters issued to the personal representative.
  • Notices received from the probate court.
  • Relevant emails, messages, or witness information.
  • Asset records, beneficiary designations, and deeds.
  • A timeline of signing, hospitalization, and other relevant events.

Preserve originals and avoid changing electronic records. Where assets include online accounts or electronic documents, the site’s article on digital estate planning explains why access and preservation should be arranged legally.

What Mistakes Should Families Avoid?

Common mistakes include waiting until the end of the 180-day period, misunderstanding the separate 42-day removal rule, filing in the wrong court, neglecting to identify necessary parties, and treating suspicion as if it were proof.

Another mistake is assuming that a beneficiary designation or deed can be challenged through the same procedure as a will. Ownership disputes, trust disputes, and claims involving alleged exploitation can have different rules and remedies. Anderson Law Group also discusses relevant inheritance concerns in its article on elder abuse and inheritance rights.

For court paperwork, the Alabama Judicial System forms library is a useful starting point, although a complex will contest may require pleadings that do not come in a standard self-help form.

Final Thoughts

Alabama Act 2026-226 clarifies the process for moving qualifying will contests and estate-administration matters to circuit court, effective October 1, 2026. The amendment restores language about removal without assigning special equity while leaving important requirements intact.

Families should distinguish the deadline for contesting a will from the deadline for transferring a pending contest, confirm the proper court, and preserve relevant estate documents. This article is general educational information, not legal advice for an individual will, estate, or dispute.